Troubleshooting Cyclone Dust Collectors

February 14th, 2018

Cyclone dust collectors are so named because they utilize a basic cyclonic effect to centrifugally separate dust from the carrying air or gas stream. The conveying gas stream enters the cyclone separator through an inlet opening at the top of the collector. The stream enters tangentially or involutely depending on equipment design (Fig. 1). The conveying gas and particulate spiral down against the outer wall and the dust is removed from the airstream by centrifugal force. Particulate is deposited on the cyclone wall where it falls into the receiver hopper under the force of gravity. The gas stream with particulate removed seeks the inner vortex and exits as clean air at the top (Fig. 2).

Design relationships between inlet, body, cone, outlet pipe, discharge hopper, and air lock determine specific unit efficiency.  The degree of removal (collection efficiency) is dependent upon many factors that individually, or in combination, create a significant variation from the original design efficiency. Collection efficiency is measured by comparing the weight of the particulate per unit time entering the collector to that leaving in the clean air discharge:

E = (Pe − Pl)/Pe X 100
E = efficiency, percent
Pe = entering particulate, lb/hr
Pl = leaving particulate, lb/hr

Efficiency is affected by changes in several parameters:

  1. Carrying air or gas volume (acfm)
  2. Temperature, pressure, and ambient humidity that affect gas density and/or viscosity
  3. Changes in the dust loading (lb/hr) or grain loading (gr/cu ft)
  4. Changes in aerodynamic particle size distribution of the particulate matter to be collected
  5. Installation factors

Installation of cyclone dust collectors should follow industry-accepted criteria. To assure proper performance, intake duct-work must be designed so that sufficiently high velocities are maintained for particulates to remain airborne as they are conveyed to the cyclone.

For maximum cyclone efficiency, it is important that ductwork be properly engineered. When possible, elbows or bends in ductwork upstream of the cyclone should direct entering air in the same rotational direction as the cyclone itself (fig3).

Static electricity buildup has detrimental effects on cyclone performance. Static charge buildup increases with grain load. Collectors must be properly grounded to eliminate dust buildup on their internal surfaces.

Installation should include a vortex-breaking receiver hoper and air lock. This equipment balances the airflow leaving the top of the reverse flow cyclone with the entering airflow. Improper discharge conditions provide the potential for product reentrainment into the outgoing airflow.
Care should be taken during installation and operation to prevent damage to duct or cyclone walls. Dents have an adverse effect on collection efficiency.

Identifying Cyclone Problems

Since a cyclone dust collector has no moving parts to fail, identification of problems is relatively straightforward.  A cyclone that works well initially but deteriorates with time usually has a different set of problems than a cyclone that operates poorly from the offset. Poor initial operation is caused by one or more of the following problems.

  1. Poorly defined operating conditions. These conditions include lack of volume and lowering of inlet velocity, changes in the design conveying-gas density, specific gravity, or grain load.
  2. Foreign objects left inside the unit during installation. Flower patterns are adversely effected.
  3. Poorly or nonseated mounting bolts and gaskets. When these occur at flange joints or access doors, leakage and loss of efficiency result.
  4. Internal condensation. Buildup of particulate on walls quickly degenerates operating conditions.
  5. Good initial operation that begins to deteriorate is caused by several conditions.
  6. Improper or degraded electrical grounding. Static electricity results in material buildup and deteriorating operation. Buildup or bridging of material is also caused by changes in operating conditions. These conditions include changes in temperature and moisture content of the airstream. Internal surface conditions such as dents, crevices, welds, ledges, or other “dead” spots provide a site for these to build on.
  7. Air leakage due to wear or damage. Abrasive particulate causes clearances to increase between the rotor and housing of rotary lock valves. Worn or damaged access doors, equipment flanges, ports, and abrasion holes also degrade performance over time. Abrasion is magnified in the lower cyclone due to higher stresses occurring in this area caused by the weight of the air lock valve.
  8. Reentrainment of particulate

Troubleshooting Tools

Basic tools of the trade are the eyes, ears, and nose of the person looking for the cause of the problem. Maintenance personnel who work with dust collectors usually see, hear, and/or smell departures from normal operation. Visual changes in outlet opacity, audible changes in flow volume or velocity, and changes in operating temperature (often detectable by smell) provide early warnings.

Other tools required are thermometers, a pitot tube, and a manometer. Leak-checking equipment to verify leakage from damage or wear is also helpful. Abrasive dusts wear holes in cyclone or duct walls. Leaks of this type reduce efficiency and cause reentrainment of fine dusts.

Measuring equipment is used to compare initial design values provided by the cyclone manufacturer to actual values for rating performance. Initial values include design temperature at key locations, average velocity pressures in ducts *convertible to actual air volume), and static pressure at the inlet and outlet of a collector. Changes in pressure drop from original design values provide evidence that a variation has occurred in a cyclone’s operation.

Since all cyclone proposals should include a performance calculation showing the pressure drop at the design flow conditions, this pressure drop should be verified with only the fan running prior to dust being introduced into the system.

A reduction in pressure drop from the baseline indicates inlet flow is less than intended. An increase in pressure drop indicates increased flow, presence of a restriction, or a change in system operating temperature.

The outgoing clean air or gas stream should contain little particulate and appear clean. Leakage on the intake side of the system, material buildup, or bridging cause more particulate to be carried out with the clean gas. Deteriorating opacity usually indicates flow alteration.

Condensation and Other Problems

An uninsulated cyclone is a good heat exchanger. In hot gas operations, internal condensation can occur, causing certain materials to accumulate and bridge across the ductwork to restrict flow. Changes in color or stickiness, or clumping in discharged particulate, often indicate the presence of condensation. Some buildups due to condensation are avoided by insulating the equipment.

A cyclone that is prone to occasional buildup is also subject to occasional abuse. Well-intentioned workers often loosen buildup by banging on duct sheet metal with a hammer or other heavy object. Since this treatment often causes dents, which alter internal flow patterns, it should be avoided. Use of vibration equipment is preferable.

Some buildups are due to the sticky nature of materials handled. In these cases, interior polishing or application of special nonstick coatings prevent problems.

Proper cyclone selection is based on accurate definition of gas and particulate inlet conditions. Reliable manufacturers accurately predict the expected efficiency and pressure drop from this data. Accurate operating data determined at startup provides the benchmark for future assessment of system operation.



Pumps for the Asphalt Industry

November 3rd, 2017

Overview Tuthill has over 75 years of experience manufacturing a wide range of positive displacement pumps that address many of the challenging applications in the asphalt industry.  Tuthill is a leading manufacturer of positive displacement pumps that serve a variety of applications in the asphalt and related building materials industries.   Asphalt Industry Applications Since […]

Beyond the Broom

October 5th, 2017

The sweeping or blowing of fugitive dust during housekeeping is widely discouraged by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA).  Though seemingly benign, dust can create an assortment of hazards, ranging from ergonomic injuries and flying particles that can lead to eye injury to more serious respiratory and […]

Pleated Bags Extend Filter Life and Reduce Downtime

August 14th, 2017

Industry: Grain Problem: Short filter life and high maintenance costs Solution: Donaldson Torit® hydrophobic / oleophobic pleated bags High Humidity Environment Costs Time and Money A grain terminal in the southern United States had a major maintenance cost issue. Baghouse filter bags needed replacing every 6 – 8 months due to excessive dust caking caused […]

Taylor Products Model IPO Open Mouth Bag Impeller Packer

November 20th, 2015

Taylor Products Model IPO Open Mouth Bag Impeller Packer The Taylor Model IPO was designed for practical performance on heavy, dense, difficult-to-feed powders, and fine granular mixtures. The Model IPO utilizes felt split shaft seals on the rotating impeller and feed screw drive shaft to prevent leakage and screws are used to keep the material […]

Smoot Blower Package Parts and Components

November 13th, 2015

Smoot Blower Package Parts and Components POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT BLOWERS The workhorse of the pneumatic conveying industry today, the Positive Displacement Blower Package offers a cost effective reliable means of generating consistent airflows from 60 to 8,000 ICFM with pressures up to 25 PSIG. With nearly 50 years of industry experience, Smoot’s package design provides a […]

ProMinent Sigma/ 3 Pumps

November 6th, 2015

ProMinent® Sigma/ 3 Pumps New Technology, Durable Design  The ProMinent® Sigma/ 3 microprocessor controlled metering pumps are programmable and display informative data for monitoring, recording, and tracking. Functions include digital setting of stroke frequency, digital stroke length adjustment, integral variable speed and access codes. Displays include flow rate (gph or l/h) and totalized flow (gallons […]

Duall: QuintEssential Scrubbing System Solves Odor Complaints

October 23rd, 2015

QuintEssential™ Scrubbing System Solves Odor Complaints Background Master Chemical Corp., an international supplier of industrial cleaners, had received complaints from workers concerning the air quality within their facility. A neighboring resident had also lodged a complaint about the odor outside of the building. Master Chemical’s existing filter unit with exhaust fan plugged quickly, choking down […]

Fisher-Klosterman Packed Towers

October 16th, 2015

Fisher-Klosterman® Packed Towers The packed tower or packed bed scrubber is used for the removal of gaseous, fume, or mist contaminants from an air stream. Packed Bed Scrubbers are relatively simple devices with potentially very complex chemistry. A well designed packed tower takes into consideration many factors and each application must be analyzed very carefully […]

Aerovent Gas Door Air Heaters

October 9th, 2015

AEROVENT GAS DOOR AIR HEATERS Solve Loading Dock Heating Problems Temper Blast of Cold Air When Overhead Door is Open Compact Packaged Construction Easy Installation Direct Gas-Fired Heating For Maximum Efficiency Application The Aerovent Automatic Door Air Heater tempers the sudden influx of cold air when an overhead door is open. To mix hot and […]